Did you read recent news reports on the “new good men” survey done in Taipei, Hong Kong, Shanghai, and Beijing? What do you know about this survey and its results? What was your reaction?
available : able to be obtained, used, or reached • breadth : when something includes many different items, features, subjects or qualities • career : the job or series of jobs that you do during your working life, especially if you continue to get better jobs and earn more money • contemporary : existing or happening now • define : to say what the meaning of something, especially a word, is • disgrace : to be so bad or unacceptable that you make people lose respect for the group or activity you are connected to • distinguish : to notice or understand the difference between two things, or to make one person or thing seem different from another • double standard : a rule or standard of good behavior which, unfairly, some people are expected to follow or achieve but other people are not • equality : the right of different groups of people to have a similar social position and receive the same treatment • fortunate : lucky • harm : to hurt someone or damage something • keep something to yourself : to keep something secret • liberated : not following traditional ways of behaving or old ideas • male chauvinist : a man who believes that women are naturally less important, intelligent or able than men, and so does not treat men and women equally • mark of : a quality or action which is understood to represent or show a characteristic of a person or thing or feeling • material: relating to physical objects or money rather than emotions or the spiritual world • no wonder : it is not surprising • prerogative : something which some people are able or allowed to do or have, but which is not possible or allowed for everyone • retain : to keep or continue to have something • spouse : a person’s husband or wife • virtue : advantage or benefit • wealth : a large amount of money or valuable possessions that someone has • whine : If you whine, especially as a child, you complain or express dissatisfaction continually • worthy : deserving respect, admiration or support
Women in Taipei should not forget how fortunate they are. According to survey conducted in Taipei, Hong Kong, Beijing, and Shanghai, Taipei men are the least chauvinistic. It appears that Taiwan’s efforts over the last few years to educate people about gender equality have reduced male chauvinism. Of course, this does not mean that male chauvinism has disappeared. If men are not careful, they reveal the male chauvinist thinking that remains.
How surprised are you at the results of the survey? Do you think male chauvinism has really been reduced? If so, do you think the education in gender equality has been the reason? What are examples of male chauvinist thinking that remains? Do you think women in Taipei really are fortunate compared to women in the other cities surveyed? What about compared to women in Japan? In Western countries?
01 A worthy man must be successful in his career.
T = 55.2% | H = 59.7% | B = 53.7% | S = 57.2%
How successful would you say you have been so far in your career? How do you define success for yourself? What level of success would completely satisfy you? If you were not successful in your career, could you still be satisfied? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
02 A man should make more money and be more successful in his career than his wife.
T = 45.9% | H = 66.3% | B = 55.9% | S = 65.4%
If you’re married, do you make more money than your spouse? Would you be considered more successful than your spouse is? If you’re not married, how much difference do you think it would make if you made more money and were more successful than your spouse? What if you made less money and were less successful? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
03 Men should have certain prerogatives that are not available to women.
T = 26.7% | H = 36.3% | B = 26.4% | S = 26.1%
What are some prerogatives that men enjoy that women do not? What about prerogatives that women enjoy that men do not? Overall, how close do you think men and women are to enjoying equal rights? Do you think it would be a good thing if they enjoyed exactly the same rights? Do you think it is possible for this situation to come about? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
04 A real man should be strong, and keep his troubles to himself.
T = 25.6% | H = 31.5% | B = 35.2% | S = 36.6%
Do you tend to keep your troubles to yourself? Whom do you most often tell your troubles to? Would you agree that men tend to keep their troubles to themselves more than do women? If so, why do you think men are like this? Do you prefer that your friends or romantic partner share their troubles with you or keep their troubles to themselves for the most part? How do you distinguish between sharing troubles and whining? Have you ever known someone whom you thought complained too much? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects how many men truly agree with it?
05 A man should solve his problems by himself.
T = 21.4% | H = 31.5% | B = 54.2% | S = 57.2%
Would you agree that men tend to try to solve their problems on their own more than do women? If so, what do you think is the reason? Do you generally try to solve your problems on your own? What would you say was the most difficult problem you have ever faced? How did you deal with this problem? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
06 The most important mark of a successful man is material wealth.
T = 17.4% | H = 38.5% | B = 20.7% | S = 26.5%
What do you think is the most important mark of a successful man? What about the mark of a successful woman? How much material wealth would you need to have before you were satisfied? How do you define success for yourself? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
07 It is best if a man does not do work that is traditionally done by women.
T = 15.3% | H = 21.2% | B = 26.9% | S = 31.5%
What jobs do you think men should avoid? Do you think women should avoid some jobs that are traditionally done by men? Have you ever done work that is traditionally by someone of the opposite sex? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
08 The most important mark of a successful man is a great breadth and depth of knowledge.
T = 5.7% | H = 12.8% | B = 22.5% | S = 16.7%
Why do you agree or disagree with this statement? Do you think in general that men have a greater breadth and depth of knowledge than do women? If so, why do you think this happens? Would you say that your knowledge is greater in depth or breadth? About what subject is your knowledge deepest? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
09 The demands put on men by society are too great, harming men.
T = 5.7% | H = 8.4% | B = 6.2% | S = 4.7%
Why do you agree or disagree with this statement? Do you believe that the demands that society puts on men are greater than on women? Do you think there are fewer demands placed on men than before, or more? What about the demands on women? How often do you feel social pressure to do things or behave in ways that you dislike? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
10 A man who stays at home while his wife works is a disgrace.
T = 3.6% | H = 5.5% | B = 5.3% | S = 4.7%
Why do you agree or disagree with this statement? Have you known any “househusbands”? If so, what were the circumstances under which they became househusbands? How did it work out? Would you like to stay at home while your spouse works outside the home? Why or why not? Do you find anything surprising about the survey results for this item? Do you think the percentage of Taipei men who said they agreed with the statement in the survey accurately reflects the percentage of men who truly agree with it?
While Taipei men are more contemporary in their outlook than men in the other three cities surveyed, women’s double standard confuses them. On the one hand, women want men to be more liberated, but on the other, they want men to retain traditional male virtues—like strength, the ability to earn much money, be successful in the eyes of society, and not seek to be a househusband. With such a double standard, it is no wonder that men cannot figure out what women really want.
Do you agree that women do have a double standard for men? If not, can you explain why there is no double standard? If you’re a woman, do you want the things from men that are mentioned? If you are a man, do you often feel confused about what women really want?
